Star Trek opens today and it's getting rave reviews. I refuse to see it. Why? Because it's fucking with the established timeline of the Trek universe.
I'm a comic book and sci-fi geek. I hate reboots with a passion. Sometimes things need reset because it's becoming confusing (see DC's
Crisis on Infinite Earths) but usually they are done because some new jack-ass shows up on scene with the idea that he can make something better. The jack ass is usually wrong.
I am currently watching the original series. I'm nearly done with season one and it's a great show. The writing is far beyond most television shows, the acting is decent (sometimes wooden, but c'mon, we live in the generation of Keanu Reeves) and the special effects are mediocre at best. But what matters is that the show's foundation isn't the special effects but the writing and the characters. Most modern movies don't understand that. The Star War Prequels are the best example--crappy story, crappy writing, crappy characters and over the top effects.
But here are just some of my gripes from just the previews and reviews:
- The crew did not attend academy together. You never get that sense from the original series; at most it's possible that McCoy and Kirk know each other but that's it. The rest have been thrown together on a ship and that's where the frienship starts.
- Sulu doesn't know how to fence. He is shown fencing, but it's because he is a swashbuckler at heart and had a desire to learn fencing. So now he is a martial arts master?
- Both Kirk and Spock lust after Uhura? Um, no. Honestly, Uhura is the one woman in the series Kirk never lusts after. Random alien girl/android/Janis Rand? Sure. And Spock? There's that whole ponfar thing.
Why doesn't just take a shit over his own creations? You know, like
Lost or
Cloverfield? Right, because this is about making money so he's going to ignore the canon to make it "better."
Good luck with that, because no matter what the reviews say,
STtOS is still going to kick this movie's ass when it comes to actual quality.